Is Your Website Actually Working?
- Design Twist
- Jan 25
- 4 min read
A Practical Checklist for High-Performing Business Websites
Your website exists. Great. But here’s the real question: is it actually doing anything useful for your business?
A surprising number of business websites are technically “fine” while quietly underperforming—confusing visitors, hiding key information, or failing to convert interest into action. And because nothing is broken, the problems often go unnoticed.
This practical checklist helps you self-diagnose whether your website is truly working—or just taking up digital real estate.
Grab a coffee. Be honest. Let’s go.
1. Is Your Message Clear in the First 5 Seconds?
When someone lands on your homepage, they should immediately understand:
What you do
Who you do it for
Why it matters
If your headline is vague, clever-but-confusing, or filled with internal jargon, visitors won’t stick around long enough to figure it out.
The Nielsen Norman Group consistently finds that users scan first and decide fast. If clarity isn’t immediate, they bounce.
Quick check: Can a stranger explain your business after glancing at your homepage for five seconds? If not, your messaging needs work.
2. Is It Easy to Use (or Slightly Annoying)?
Usability issues rarely announce themselves. They quietly frustrate users until they leave.
Red flags include:
Confusing navigation
Too many menu options
Important information is buried three clicks deep
Forms that feel unnecessarily long
A high-performing website guides visitors naturally toward action. If users have to think too hard, the design isn’t doing its job.
3. Does Your Website Work Properly on Mobile?
This one’s non-negotiable.
More than half of all web traffic is mobile, and Google uses mobile-first indexing when ranking websites. If your site technically “works” on a phone but feels awkward or cramped, that’s still a problem.
You can test performance using Google PageSpeed Insights:
If mobile usability feels like an afterthought, it’s often a sign your website is overdue for professional attention.
4. Does It Feel Trustworthy and Up to Date?
People judge credibility fast—and design plays a huge role.
Ask yourself:
Does the site look modern and polished?
Are fonts readable and layouts clean?
Are images high quality and relevant?
Does anything feel dated or neglected?
An outdated website can quietly undermine even the strongest brand. Visitors may not say, “This site looks old,” but they will feel it—and act accordingly.
5. Is Your Website Accessible to Everyone?
Accessibility isn’t just a nice-to-have—it’s increasingly a business and legal consideration.
Basic accessibility checks include:
Sufficient colour contrast
Readable font sizes
Clear headings and structure
Alt text for images
The Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI) offers helpful guidance on inclusive design best practices:👉 https://www.w3.org/WAI/
If accessibility wasn’t considered during your original build, a review—or redesign—may be necessary.
6. Is Your Website Helping or Hurting Your SEO?
A website can look great and still perform poorly in search.
Common SEO issues include:
Slow load times
Poor page structure
Duplicate or thin content
Missing metadata
If you’re investing in content or marketing but not seeing results, the site itself may be the bottleneck. A strategic website refresh often improves SEO foundations significantly—especially when guided by an experienced web design agency.
For a solid overview of SEO basics, Moz offers an excellent resource:
7. Does Your Website Encourage Action?
This is the big one.
A high-performing business website should make it obvious what to do next:
Contact you
Book a consultation
Request information
Sign up
If calls to action are unclear, inconsistent, or missing altogether, your website may be quietly leaking opportunities.
According to HubSpot, clear CTAs significantly improve conversion rates:
Traffic without conversion is just noise.
8. Can You Update It Without Stress?
If updating your website feels risky, confusing, or impossible, that’s a serious limitation.
Modern websites should allow you to:
Update content easily
Add pages without breaking layouts
Keep information current
When businesses avoid making updates because the system is clunky, the site quickly becomes outdated—and less effective over time.
So… Is Your Website Actually Working?
If you answered “no,” “maybe,” or “I’m not sure” to several of these questions, your website may be doing less than you think—and costing you more than you realize.
The good news? These issues are fixable. The better news? Identifying them is the first step.
Whether that means targeted improvements or a full strategic overhaul, a professional web
design agency can help turn your website into a tool that supports growth instead of quietly holding it back.
Because your website shouldn’t just exist. It should work—clearly, confidently, and consistently.
Ready to Find Out What Your Website Is Really Doing?
If this checklist raised a few red flags—or even a quiet “uh oh”—you’re not alone. Most businesses don’t realize their website is underperforming until they stop and look at it strategically.
The good news? You don’t have to figure it out on your own.
A professional website review can quickly uncover:
Why visitors aren’t converting
Where usability or messaging is breaking down
Whether your site is holding back SEO and growth
What improvements will make the biggest impact (and which won’t)
If you’re wondering whether your website needs targeted improvements or a full redesign, working with an experienced web design agency can save you time, money, and guesswork.
Let’s turn your website into a tool that actually works for your business.
👉 Book a website audit / discovery call / consultation👉 Get expert insight, clear recommendations, and a path forward
Because your website shouldn’t just look good—it should pull its weight.
Comments